2026 Affordability Data
Most Affordable Neighborhoods in St. Marys - 2026 Data
The median home value in St. Marys is $140,100, 50% below nat'l avg. Median rent is $748/month. With an affordability index of 158, St. Marys is more affordable than the national baseline of 100. We ranked 15 neighborhoods by affordability to help you find the best value in the St. Marys, PA area.
Key Takeaways: Affordability in St. Marys
- 1The most affordable neighborhood in St. Marys is Oil City, with a median home value of $59,900.
- 2St. Marys's median home value is $140,100, 50% below nat'l avg (national: $281,900).
- 3St. Marys's affordability index is 158 (baseline 100), making it more affordable than the national average.
- 4Median rent in St. Marys is $748/month, 36% below nat'l avg (national: $1,163/month).
- 5We analyzed 15 neighborhoods in St. Marys to find the most affordable areas based on home values, rent, and affordability index.
St. Marys Affordability Overview
Median Home Value
$140,100
50% below nat'l avg
Median Rent
$748/mo
36% below nat'l avg
Median Income
$61,364
18% below nat'l avg
Affordability Index
158
58% above nat'l avg
Most Affordable Neighborhoods in St. Marys (Ranked)
| Rank | Neighborhood | Median Home Value |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Oil CityPA | $59,900 |
| 2 | Quakertown boroughPA | $241,600 |
| 3 | MeadvillePA | $136,200 |
| 4 | ScrantonPA | $125,700 |
| 5 | Lower BurrellPA | $180,700 |
| 6 | Conshohocken boroughPA | $381,100 |
| 7 | Franklin Park boroughPA | $436,300 |
| 8 | EriePA | $101,500 |
| 9 | Kingston boroughPA | $146,700 |
| 10 | BethlehemPA | $220,300 |
| 11 | Whitehall boroughPA | $215,000 |
| 12 | GreensburgPA | $160,600 |
| 13 | YorkPA | $92,600 |
| 14 | Wilkes-BarrePA | $98,200 |
| 15 | HazletonPA | $119,700 |
Detailed Neighborhood Profiles
Home Value: $59,900
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 9,599
Walk Score: 1/100
Home Value: $241,600
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 9,309
Walk Score: 1/100
Home Value: $136,200
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 12,929
Walk Score: 1/100
4
Home Value: $125,700
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 76,119
Walk Score: 1/100
5
Home Value: $180,700
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 11,701
Walk Score: 1/100
6
Home Value: $381,100
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 9,182
Walk Score: 1/100
7
Home Value: $436,300
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 15,305
Walk Score: 1/100
8
Home Value: $101,500
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 94,826
Walk Score: 1/100
9
Home Value: $146,700
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 13,317
Walk Score: 1/100
10
Home Value: $220,300
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 76,555
Walk Score: 1/100
11
Home Value: $215,000
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 14,909
Walk Score: 1/100
12
Home Value: $160,600
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 14,876
Walk Score: 1/100
13
Home Value: $92,600
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 44,782
Walk Score: 1/100
14
Home Value: $98,200
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 44,123
Walk Score: 1/100
15
Home Value: $119,700
Rent: $748/mo
Affordability: 158
Population: 29,671
Walk Score: 1/100
Frequently Asked Questions About Affordability in St. Marys
What is the most affordable neighborhood in St. Marys, PA?▾
Based on 2026 data, Oil City is the most affordable neighborhood in St. Marys with a median home value of $59,900. Kurby analyzed 15 neighborhoods in the St. Marys area to compile these rankings.
What is the median home price in St. Marys, PA?▾
The median home price in St. Marys is $140,100, which is 50% below nat'l avg. The national median home value is $281,900 (Source: Kurby, 2026).
Is St. Marys affordable compared to the national average?▾
St. Marys has an affordability index of 158, which means housing is more affordable than the national baseline of 100. An index above 100 indicates that a median-income household can afford a median-priced home in the area.
What is the average rent in St. Marys, PA?▾
The median monthly rent in St. Marys is $748. This is 36% below nat'l avg. The national median rent is $1,163/month (Source: Kurby, 2026).
What is the median household income in St. Marys?▾
The median household income in St. Marys is $61,364 compared to the national median of $74,580. This metric is important for understanding housing affordability in relation to local earning power (Source: Kurby, 2026).
How many neighborhoods in St. Marys are below the national average home price?▾
13 out of 15 ranked neighborhoods in St. Marys have a median home value below the national average of $281,900. The most affordable is Oil City at $59,900 (Source: Kurby, 2026).