New: Get Kurby insights right inside Zillow, Trulia, and Redfin

    Add to Chrome
    logo
    M

    Middle Island CDP

    New York

    Family-Friendly
    About Middle Island CDP

    Nestled on the North Shore of Long Island, Middle Island offers a refreshing take on suburban living, especially for those seeking a welcoming community without breaking the bank. With a population of just over 10,700, the area fosters a close-knit atmosphere, perfect for families. The median home value here is a steal at around $323,000, significantly below the national average. This affordability, coupled with a median household income of approximately $85,700, exceeding the national median, allows residents to enjoy a comfortable lifestyle. Middle Island is a place where neighbors know each other and the pace of life allows you to savor the simple pleasures.

    From an investment perspective, Middle Island presents a compelling opportunity, particularly for those seeking a stable, family-oriented environment. While specific unemployment figures aren't readily available, the area's robust median income suggests a healthy job market. The housing market is competitive, with properties often moving quickly, so be prepared to act fast if you find a home you like. While the walkability score is in line with suburban norms, Middle Island's focus on safety and community makes it ideal for families with children or anyone seeking a peaceful, secure environment. If you're looking for a place to put down roots and build a life, Middle Island should be at the top of your list.

    Middle Island CDP, New York at a Glance

    Middle Island CDP is a neighborhood in New York with a population of approximately 10,731. The median home value is $322,700 and the median household income is $85,673. It has a Walk Score of 0 out of 100, indicating car dependency. The violent crime rate is 0.3 per 1,000 residents, which is 92% below the national average. Air quality is rated Good. The overall climate risk is rated as "Relatively Moderate." Median rent is $858 per month. Data sourced from the US Census Bureau, FBI Crime Data Explorer, EPA, Walk Score, and FEMA.

    Median Home Value

    $322,700

    Median Income

    $85,673

    Population

    10,731

    Walk Score

    0

    Air Quality

    AQI 40

    Good

    Climate Risk

    Relatively Moderate

    Kurby Score
    57
    C+

    Fair

    Walkability & Transit1/100
    Affordability70/100
    Safety95/100
    Economy68/100
    Environment39/100
    Education: Unavailable

    Are you a real estate agent in Middle Island CDP?

    Thousands of homebuyers research this neighborhood every month. Make sure they find you.

    Get discovered

    Your profile shown to every visitor

    Generate leads

    Direct calls, emails & website clicks

    Build authority

    Branded reports & local expert badge

    Claim this neighborhood

    Available on Pro & Enterprise plans

    Demographics
    Population
    10,731
    Median Age
    N/A
    Median Household Income
    $85,673

    15% above nat'l avg

    Bachelor's Degree+
    N/A
    Poverty Rate
    10.8%

    13% below nat'l avg

    Housing
    Median Home Value
    $322,700

    14% above nat'l avg

    Median Rent
    $858

    26% below nat'l avg

    Homeownership Rate
    83.0%

    26% above nat'l avg

    Affordability Index
    119

    19% above nat'l avg

    Safety
    Violent Crime Rate
    0.3 per 1K

    92% below nat'l avg

    Property Crime Rate
    4.4 per 1K

    77% below nat'l avg

    Livability
    Walk Score
    0 / 100

    100% below nat'l avg

    Transit Score
    N/A
    Bike Score
    1 / 100

    97% below nat'l avg

    Want a detailed report for a specific address in Middle Island CDP?

    Air Quality
    AQI
    40

    5% below nat'l avg

    Category
    Good
    GoodModerateUnhealthy
    Climate Risk
    Overall Risk
    Relatively Moderate
    Risk Score
    81.41

    Top Hazards

    Landslide
    Relatively Moderate
    Inland Flooding
    Very High
    Winter Weather
    Relatively Moderate
    Noise Levels
    Overall
    Quiet
    Road Traffic
    N/A
    Aviation
    N/A
    Rail
    N/A
    Utility Costs
    Electricity Rate
    22.5¢/kWh

    36% above nat'l avg

    Est. Monthly Electric
    $203

    48% above nat'l avg

    Employment
    Unemployment Rate
    4.2%

    14% above nat'l avg

    Poverty Rate
    10.8%

    13% below nat'l avg

    Weather & Climate in Middle Island CDP

    Avg High

    54°F

    Avg Low

    37°F

    Annual Rainfall

    47.1"

    Avg Humidity

    75%

    Monthly Temperature (°F)
    Monthly Precipitation (inches)

    Political Landscape

    Political Leaning
    Leans Republican
    DemocratRepublican

    → Politically stable

    Based on Delaware County county-level presidential election data

    Presidential Election Results

    Culture & Things to Do in Middle Island CDP

    Attractions & Landmarks
    🦁Long Island Game Farm(zoo)
    🌳Smith Point County Park(park)
    🌳Prosser Pines Nature Preserve(park)
    📜Longwood Estate(historic)
    🏗️Brookhaven Calabro Airport(landmark)
    🏗️Swan Lake(landmark)
    📜Middle Island Presbyterian Church(historic)
    🏗️Long Island Rail Road(landmark)
    Local Events & Festivals

    Middle Island Fire Department Carnival

    Annual carnival with rides, games, and food.

    Longwood Central School District Events

    Various school-related events throughout the year, open to the public.

    Brookhaven Town Events

    Events hosted by Brookhaven Town, including concerts and festivals.

    Holiday Tree Lighting Ceremony

    Community event to celebrate the holiday season with a tree lighting.

    Things to Know Before Moving

    Similar Neighborhoods in New York

    People Also Compare

    Explore New York

    Find Your Perfect Neighborhood

    Tell us what matters most to you and we'll match you with neighborhoods that fit your lifestyle and budget.