New: Get Kurby insights right inside Zillow, Trulia, and Redfin

    Add to Chrome
    logo
    S

    Shelter Island CDP

    New York

    Family-Friendly
    About Shelter Island CDP

    Shelter Island offers a unique blend of small-town charm and upscale living, making it a desirable destination for families and those seeking a tranquil escape. With a population of just over 2,500 residents, the community fosters a close-knit atmosphere where neighbors know each other and the pace of life slows down. While the median home value of $940,300 is significantly above the national average, the lifestyle and quality of life here justify the investment. The median household income of nearly $99,000 also surpasses the national benchmark, reflecting the area's affluence and the financial stability of its residents.

    From an investment perspective, Shelter Island presents a solid opportunity, particularly for those seeking a family-friendly environment. The housing market reflects the area's desirability, with properties holding their value well. While specific unemployment figures are not available, the higher median income suggests a robust local economy. Safety is another key selling point, with low crime rates contributing to the overall peace of mind. Shelter Island is an ideal choice for those seeking a safe, close-knit community with a high quality of life, offering a unique blend of natural beauty and upscale living.

    Shelter Island CDP, New York at a Glance

    Shelter Island CDP is a neighborhood in New York with a population of approximately 2,564. The median home value is $940,300 and the median household income is $98,902.. The violent crime rate is 0.3 per 1,000 residents, which is 92% below the national average.. Data sourced from the US Census Bureau, FBI Crime Data Explorer, EPA, Walk Score, and FEMA.

    Median Home Value

    $940,300

    Median Income

    $98,902

    Population

    2,564

    Walk Score

    N/A

    Air Quality

    N/A

    Climate Risk

    N/A

    Kurby ScoreLimited Data
    51
    C+

    Fair

    Affordability7/100
    Safety95/100
    Economy79/100
    Walkability & Transit: UnavailableEducation: UnavailableEnvironment: Unavailable

    Are you a real estate agent in Shelter Island CDP?

    Thousands of homebuyers research this neighborhood every month. Make sure they find you.

    Get discovered

    Your profile shown to every visitor

    Generate leads

    Direct calls, emails & website clicks

    Build authority

    Branded reports & local expert badge

    Claim this neighborhood

    Available on Pro & Enterprise plans

    Demographics
    Population
    2,564
    Median Age
    N/A
    Median Household Income
    $98,902

    33% above nat'l avg

    Bachelor's Degree+
    N/A
    Poverty Rate
    0.3%

    98% below nat'l avg

    Housing
    Median Home Value
    $940,300

    234% above nat'l avg

    Median Rent
    N/A
    Homeownership Rate
    75.5%

    15% above nat'l avg

    Affordability Index
    N/A
    Safety
    Violent Crime Rate
    0.3 per 1K

    92% below nat'l avg

    Property Crime Rate
    4.4 per 1K

    77% below nat'l avg

    Livability
    Walk Score
    N/A
    Transit Score
    N/A
    Bike Score
    N/A

    Want a detailed report for a specific address in Shelter Island CDP?

    Air Quality
    AQI
    N/A
    Category
    N/A
    Climate Risk
    Overall Risk
    N/A
    Risk Score
    N/A
    Noise Levels
    Overall
    N/A
    Road Traffic
    N/A
    Aviation
    N/A
    Rail
    N/A
    Utility Costs
    Electricity Rate
    N/A
    Est. Monthly Electric
    N/A
    Employment
    Unemployment Rate
    5.7%

    54% above nat'l avg

    Poverty Rate
    0.3%

    98% below nat'l avg

    Political Landscape

    Political Leaning
    Leans Republican
    DemocratRepublican

    → Politically stable

    Based on Delaware County county-level presidential election data

    Presidential Election Results

    Culture & Things to Do in Shelter Island CDP

    Attractions & Landmarks
    🌳Mashomack Preserve(park)
    🏛️Shelter Island Historical Society(museum)
    🏖️Wades Beach(beach)
    📜Shelter Island Heights Historic District(historic)
    📜The Pridwin Hotel and Cottages(historic)
    Local Events & Festivals

    Shelter Island 10K

    Annual 10-kilometer race.

    Shelter Island Chamber of Commerce Fireworks

    Annual fireworks display.

    Things to Know Before Moving

    Similar Neighborhoods in New York

    People Also Compare

    Explore New York

    Find Your Perfect Neighborhood

    Tell us what matters most to you and we'll match you with neighborhoods that fit your lifestyle and budget.